Splash 14 ch15 Mag Reviews
From C64 Diskmag Wiki
-------------- MAG REVIEWS -------------- hello again! it's again the ti- me to review some of the mags aro- und and give detailed information how they are doing... there are so many mags around that some object- ive critism can separate the good ones from the rest. yes,objectiveness...that is the right word.the most important thi- nk in critisizing is the objective ness although it is usually pretty hard to be hundred percent object- ive as the critisizer tries to wr- ite his own idea.but anyway,i will try to stay objective as much as i can. well,enough bullsshit. the mags reviewed for this issue are: -impulse 2 by spirit -network 3 by comic pirates IMPULSE TWO BY SPIRIT INTRO: well,the graphics of the intro are pretty cool! two out of three of the screen is covered by an impulse and a spirit logo while a swinging scroll runs down... OUTFIT: as you enter the main me- nu,the first thing that strucks is the terribly nice graphics.there's a state-of-the-art impulse logo l- ying at the top of the screen and the boxes to choose the chapters are put under that.there are eight boxes resembling the related chap- ters.they are figures,so their na- mes are stated under the screen with tech - teching chars.when you press fire to load,a loading sign replaces the chapter name. the text screen is also a well- drawn but classsic one.the name of the chapter swings upon the upsc- rolling texts.by the way,there are a lot of different ways o'display- ing the text chars.for example,so- metimes it tech-techs,sometimes it swings smoothly.also da outfit ca- rries the ability to display litt- splits... over all,the outfit is quite a classic but fairly good lookin one really... % 90 TEXT: well,it's hard to say th- at the mag contains lots of text!! to say the truth,the amount was q- uite fewer that i expected from a mag designed so nicely.spirit has a lot of kewl swappers to get the- ir hands on some more mag stuff i guess.tehy should surely try to i- mprove that! %60 OBJECTIVITY: well,so serious p- roblems with da objectivity at all if you take a look at the general of the mag. % 90 GRAPHICS: the most positive si- de with impulse is the brilliant art work.what can i say more... % 95 MUSIC: well,no problem at all! suiting to the mag very well...but not superb at all. % 80 to give an overall point,i can say that impulse is quite a promi- sing mag with nice outfit and de- termined editors.the amount of txt might have been caused by the age of the mag and this can improve in time and this will make impulse to the top ten soon,that's what i wi- sh at least. (90+60+90+95+80)/5 = %83 for overall... NETWORK 3 BY COMIC PIRATES INTRO: the intro is quite an ave- rage one and nothing special with it.after you press space,there is a trainer menu(!!) with nine ques- tions and if you say no to the la- st one(do you wanna start the game ) then you go back to the intro. OUTFIT:as you enter the main scr- een firtsly a "cp" sprite appears at the left down corner.then a net work logo on top follows by light- ening.then from the bottom the box with the chapters comes.the chap- ter names are presented with 1x1 chars and dots are animated by th- em.you choose the topic by moving up and down through the names and fire loads as a loading sign rep- laces the chapter box. the same logo's used in the te- xt menu as well.the texts are pre- sented in a box and the pages ch- ange as you wriggle the joy right and left.by the way,the box comes from the corners to the center wh- ile changing the text... anyway,quite a simple outfit... % 70 TEXT: the amount of text is not so much but ain't that little as well,so i can use the word"normal" to describe it properly.every cha- pter starts with some pirate crap but since the group's name resemb- les the pirates,this may seem qui- te reasonable.but they must still improve the amount of readable te- xt. % 70 OBJECTIVITY:well,the mag seemed quite objective,at least for me. % 95 GRAPHICS: hmm,there're too few graphics in the mag and although the present ones are nice,this is a lack of design I think. % 65 MUSICS: quite nice and suits to the mag,yet not superb... % 80 to summarize,although they lack a lot to become a top mag,i like this little,lovely and cool maga- zine among many of the rest,what can i say? 70+70+95+65+80/5 = % 76 for overall! well,that's strange.people seem to be complaining about the number of mags around,but not many mags reached me around these days.so i reviewed just two mags for this i- ssue... now an overall ranking among t- the mags reviewed in the previous issues including the new ones... 1.immortal flash 15.....%90 2.update 7..............%85 3.impulse 2.............%83 4.scene observer 2......%78 5.comic pirates 3.......%76 6.tele 64 1.............%75 7.newspress 3...........%65 8.internal 15...........%58 and that was it.in fact i ha- ve toexcuse from you as my contri- bution to this issue of splash is quite few.but the reason is simply that the editor reached me too la- te and right before my mid-term e- xaminations in the school which'll last for two week uninterrruptedly and there is at least obe exam for everyday.for example,i am writing this under a time presssure as i have to study for the exam from a lesson named "labor economics", so the end comes with the promise of much more text for the new issue! the boss of accuracy! ---------------------